The Austro-Hungarian Creation of a “Humanitarian” Pretext for the Planned Invasion of Serbia in 1912–1913: Facts and Counter-Facts

  1. The War Correspondence of Leon Trotsky: The Balkan Wars, 1912–1913 (Pathfinder Press, 1991); The Other Balkan Wars. A 1913 Carnegie Endowment Inquiry in Retrospective with New Introduction and Reflections on the Present Conflict, prefaced by George F. Kennan (Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Endowment Book, 1993), a reprint of Report of the International Commission to Inquire into Causes and Conduct of the Balkan Wars (Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 1914); Leo Freundlich: Albanian Golgotha: Indictment of the Extermination of the Albanian People (Riverdale, NY: Juka Pub. Co., 1998; first published in German, Vienna: J. Roller, 1913), http://www.albanianhistory.net/texts20_1/AH1913_1/html); Dimitrije Tucović, Srbija i Arbanija. Jedan prilog kritici zavojevačke politike srpske buržoazije (Belgrade: Most Art, 2011; first published in 1914); Die Albanische Korrespondenz. Agenturmeldung aus Krisenzeiten Juni 1913 bis August 1914, ed. Robert Elsie (Munich: Oldenburg, 2012). ↩︎
  2. The Other Balkan Wars, 1. ↩︎
  3. Justin McCarthy, Death and Exile: The Ethnic Cleansing of Ottoman Muslims, 1821–1922 (New Jersey: Princeton, 1995); Noel Malcolm, Kosovo: A Short History (London: Macmillan Publishers, 1998); Miranda Vickers, Between Serb and Albanian: A History of Kosovo (New York: Columbia University Press, 1998); Tim Judah, The Serbs, History, Myth & Destruction of Yugoslavia (New Haven, London: Yale University Press, 2000); Francois Grumel-Jacquignon, La Yougoslavie dans la stratégie française de l’entre-deux-guerres (1918–1935) aux origines du myth serbe en France (Bern: Peter Lang, 1999); Holm Sundhaussen, Geschichte Serbiens,
    19.-20. Jahrhundert
    (Vienna: Bohlau, 2007). ↩︎
  4. Maria Todorova, Imagining the Balkans (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997), esp. Foreword. ↩︎
  5. E.g. Mile Bjelajac, “The Other Side of the War: Treating Wounded and Captured Enemies by Serbian Army”, in The Salonica Theatre of Operations and the Outcome of the First World War (Thessaloniki: Institute for Balkan Studies, 2005); Mile Bjelajac, “Instrumentalizacija instrumentalizacije: Uporno oživljavanje propagandne interpetacije o dobrima i lošima na Balkanu tokom i neposredno posle Balkanskih ratova”, paper submitted at the International Conference “The First Balkan War 1912/1913: The Social and Cultural Meaning”, Vranje June 1–3, 2012. ↩︎
  6. Andrej Mitrović, Prodor na Balkan: Srbija u planovima Austro-Ugarske i Nemačke 1908–1918 (Belgrade: Nolit, 1981; 2nd ed., 2011); Bogumil Hrabak, Arbanaški upadi i pobune na Kosovu i u Makedoniji od kraja 1912. do kraja 1915. godine (Vranje: Narodni muzej, 1988); Andrej Mitrović, “Albanians in the policy of Austria-Hungary towards Serbia 1914–1918”, in Serbs and Albanians in the 20th century (Belgrade: Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts, 1991), 107–133; Novica Rakočević, “Montenegrin-Albanian Relations 1878–1914”, in Serbia and the Albanians in the 19th and Early 20th Centuries (Belgrade: Serbian Academy of Science
    and Arts, 1990), 61–197; Teodora Toleva, Uticaj Austrougarske imperije na stvaranje albanske nacije 1896–1908, transl. from Bulgarian (Belgrade: Filip Visnjic, 2016). ↩︎
  7. By a ‘Special Correspondent’ [Cyril Campbell], The Balkan War Drama (London: Andrew Melrose, 1913), 181. Campbell was a correspondent for the London Times. ↩︎
  8. Rakočević, “Montenegrin-Albanian Relations”, 167. ↩︎
  9. Dokumenti o spoljnoj politici Kraljevine Srbije [Documents on the Foreign Policy of the
    Kingdom of Serbia; hereafter DSPKS], from 5 October 1912 to 31 December 1912 (Bel-
    grade: Serbian Academy of Science and Arts, 1986, vol. 5/III, doc. 351, Rakić to Pašić, 18
    Nov. (1 Dec.) 1912. ↩︎
  10. Ibid. doc. 262, pp. 362–364, Report of 7/20 Nov. 1912. ↩︎
  11. Hrabak, Arbanaški upadi i pobune, 19 (based on HHSA, PA XXXVIII, box 405, No 3458, von Pözel from Prizren, 23 March 1913, tlg. no.15; tlg. no.10. of 7 March 1913) ↩︎
  12. Henrik August Angell, Naar et lidet Folk Kjamper for Livet. Serbiske soldaterfortallinger (Kristiania: H. Aschehoug & Co. (W. Nygaard), 1914), Serb. ed.: Kad se jedan mali narod bori za život. Srpske vojničke priče (Belgrade: Itaka, 1995), 19, 20, 73–77. ↩︎
  13. Balkan War Drama, 184. He also added a comment: “Enough, however, has been said to show how in many cases the Press is used, often, alas, deliberately, to stir up the vilest passions of men.” ↩︎
  14. Stanoje M. Mijatović, Iz rata u rat, 1912–1920: ratni dnevnik (Belgrade: Potez, 2004), 14; General Miloje Jelisijević, “Ibarska vojska u ratu 1912 godine”, Ratnik XI-XII (1928), 27, stated that enemy casualties during the battle for Novi Pazar were 300 dead, 700 wounded and around 200 captured. ↩︎
  15. Politika (Belgrade), 30 Sept./13 Oct. 1912; 5/18 Oct. 1912; 11/24 Oct. 1912, ↩︎
  16. Zločini nad Albancima u Balkanskim ratovima, http://sh.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zločini_nad_Albancima_u_Balkanskim ratovima, Wikipedia, NYT article: “Servian Army left a Trail of Blood” (Say Hungarian Reports), 31 December 1912. ↩︎
  17. Mile Bjelajac and Predrag Trifunović, Izmedju vojske i politike. Biografija generala Dušana Trifunovića 1880–1942 (Belgrade: INIS, Kruševac: Muzej Kruševca, 1997). Trifunović was the Chief of Staff in the Javor Brigade (12,000 men). I have never seen any document that suggests any difficulties with the civilian population in their war zone. On the contrary, it was frequently reported that refugees returned to their homes soon. A person who alleged that Sjenica was the scene of such horror apparently did not know that it was too small a place to have as many as 950 notables. ↩︎
  18. Mijatović, “Iz rata u rat”, 17 (entry for 8 Nov. 1912). ↩︎
  19. Srpske novine, 10/23 Nov. 1912, report of 9/22 Nov. from Skopje. ↩︎
  20. Trotsky, The Balkan Wars, 290. ↩︎
  21. Politika, 22 Oct./2 Nov. 1912; 27 Oct./9 Nov. 1912. ↩︎
  22. Freundlich, Albania’s Golgotha (http://www.albanianhistory.net/texts20_1/AH1913_1/html). ↩︎
  23. Kosta Novaković, Srbizacija i kolonizacija Kosova (http://sh.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zločini_nad_Albancima_u_Balkanskim ratovima). ↩︎
  24. Malcolm, Kosovo, 254. Malcolm considers the claim that 120,000 fled in exile probably overestimated. He referred to the Austrian official record that 20,000 men from the Gjakova district and 30,000 from Prizren had fled into Bosnia, together with 21,000 from the Muslim clans of those areas (ibid. 358); Sundhaussen gives the estimates of 20,000 killed and 60,000 forced into exile (H. Sundhaussen (Serbian edition), 238). ↩︎
  25. Tamara Sheer, “The First Balkan War from the Perspective of Habsburg Empire’s German Media”, in The Balkan Wars 1912/1913: New Views and Interpretation (Belgrade: Strategic Institute and Institute of History, 2013), 277–291. ↩︎
  26. Johannes Tangeberg, “Semi-barbarians, courageous patriots and Orientals: Swedish views of the Balkan Wars in 1912–1913”, Annual of Social History 11/1 (2004), 55–69. ↩︎
  27. Malcolm, Kosovo, 257–258 (based on the Kohlruss report, 18 Sept. 1913 (Fshaj); Cana Socialdemokracia, p. 147 (Fshaj) ↩︎
  28. Albanische Korrespondenz Büro, Vienna 16 September 1913; Radničke novine, Telegrami, 18 Sept. 1913. ↩︎
  29. Trotsky, The Balkan Wars, 121. ↩︎
  30. Medjunarodno ratno pravo sa pravilnikom (Belgrade), 3, ad. 17 (When reprisal is allowed: When one belligerent does not respect the Law of War, the other one has the right to return “eye for an eye”. The order for reprisal should be issued by the commander of the troops against whom violation of the law was committed … Retaliation must not be applied on peaceful civilians.) ↩︎
  31. Velimir Ivetić, “Brutality of all the participants of the Balkans Wars according to Holm Sundhaussen. The case of Serbia in the First Balkan War”, paper submitted at the International Conference “First Balkan War 1912/1913: The Social and Cultural Meaning”, Vranje 1–3 June 2012, 8–9 (based on Vojni arhiv [Military Archives; hereafter VA], Belgrade, P 2, f 1, g 2, doc. 1). ↩︎
  32. An extract from King Peter’s Proclamation to his Army, October 1912, in Bjelajac, “The Other Side of the War”, (based on Aleksandar M. Stojićević, Istorija naših ratova za oslobodjenje i ujedinjenje od 1912–1918 (Belgrade: Štamparija Gl. Saveza Srpskih Zemljorad Zadruga 1932), 69). For a distorted translation of this proclamation see Freundlich, Albania’s Golgotha (http://www.albanianhistory.net/texts20_1/AH1913_1/html). ↩︎
  33. An extract from Prince Alexander’s order to his First Army, in Bjelajac, “The Other Side of the War”, 128. ↩︎
  34. The instruction of General Radomir Putnik, Chief of the General Staff, during his meeting with the highest officers of the First Army in Vranjska Banja, 3/16 Oct. 1912, in Dragutin Milutinović, Timočka divizija II poziva u I i II Balkanskom ratu 1912–1913 (Belgrade: Štamparija Skerlić, 1926), 12. ↩︎
  35. Srpske novine, 6/18 Oct. ↩︎
  36. Srpske novine, 11/23 Oct. 1912, Review of the Press. ↩︎
  37. Srpske novine, 13/26 Oct. 1912, Review of the Press: Die Zeit, 22 Oct. 1912 (“Too late”). ↩︎
  38. Ivetić, “Brutality”, 21–22, n. 57, quotes the whole instruction in nine points (based on VA, P 2, box 18, f 1, doc. 2 and 3). ↩︎
  39. Miroslav Svirčević, Lokalna uprava i razvoj moderne srpske države (Belgrade: Balkanološki institut SANU, 2011), 547–549. ↩︎
  40. Similar suggestions also came from other quarters. The first mayor of Skopje, Panta Gavrilović, suggested to the Supreme Command to order that local notables and their properties in the environs of the city must be protected. In his words, the Christians still plundered their lands and possessions outside the city. Since they had a great influence on local Muslims (mostly Turks and some Albanians), it would be useful to win them over by being sympathetic and meeting their needs. See DSPKS, vol. 5/III, doc. 122, p. 245, 24 Oct./6 Nov. 1912. ↩︎
  41. VA, P 2, box 50, f 1, 1/7, Third Army Command, Prizren, 8 March 1913, to Mayor of Prizren; Chief of Prizren District; Commanders of the Šumadija Division 1st and 2nd age groups; Kosovo Divisional District; Commander of the City of Djakovica. The request was transmitted to the Chief of Novi Pazar District too. ↩︎
  42. Rakočević, “Montenegrin-Albanian Relations”, 193–194; See also DSPKS, vol. 5/III, docs. 198, 209, 256 (HQ of the Serbian Third Army to the Supreme Command on the situation in Djakovica, 7/20 November 1912), doc. 303 (Prime Minister to the Legation in Montenegro, on the situation in Sjenica and Prijepolje, 14/27 November 1912). ↩︎
  43. VA, P 2, box 18, f 33, doc 1. See also VA, P 2, Box 52, f 32, doc 16. ↩︎
  44. VA, P 2, box 50, f 1, 1, 1/1 VK [Supreme Command] ord. no. 2547, 4 Jan. 1913, to Commander of Third Army in Prizren 12:53 h. ↩︎
  45. DSPKS, vol. 5/III, doc. 317, Supreme Command no. 1292, 15/28 Nov. 1912. Prime Minister Pašić made a note on the verso: “To tell the Bulgarian and Greek commands to issue orders for withdrawal, otherwise the military would pursue them because they are in the habit of plundering”. ↩︎
  46. Milutinović, Timočka divizija, 48. ↩︎
  47. Ivetić, “Brutality”, n. 32 (based on VA, P 2, box 47, f 2; box 49 f 23; box 64, f 1); On Priština, see also Stanislav Krakov, Ratni dnevnici 1912–1916 (Novi Sad: Prometej; Belgrade: RTS, 2019), 45–57. ↩︎
  48. Nikola Hristić (Colonel), “Zauzeće Prizrena i Djakovice 1912 godine”, Ratnik, VII–VIII (1926), 50 (operational diary). ↩︎
  49. VA, P 2, box 13, f 1, doc. 2, 1/3. Two letters from Fr Mitrofan to General Živković (Mitrovica), 22 Oct./4 Nov. 1912; 29 Oct./11 Nov. 1912 ↩︎
  50. Borisav Ratković, Oslobodjenje Kosova i Metohije 1912 (Belgrade 1997), 258–268. ↩︎
  51. Nikola Hristić (Colonel), “Marš Drinskog konjičkog eskadrona II poziva kroz Albaniju 1912 godine”, Ratnik IX (Sept. 1926), 52–76; Dušan D. Krsitić (Colonel), “Operacije Albanskog odreda 1912 godine”, Ratnik V (May 1927), 32–50; Vojislav U. Ilić (Colonel), “Operacije Jadranskih odreda ka Jadranu 1912–1913”, Ratnik XII (Dec. 1937), 32–42; I ( Jan. 1938), 42–53; Dragiša Vasić, Karakter i mentalitet jednog pokolenja (Belgrade: 1919; reprinted Belgrad: Altera, 1990), 37–38. ↩︎
  52. Ratković, Oslobodjenje Kosova i Metohije. ↩︎
  53. DSPKS, vol. 5/III, doc. 262, pp. 362–364, Report of the Third Army to the Supreme Command, 7/20 Nov. 1912 and Annex on the conducted investigation in 22 points, Prizren, 1/14 Nov. 1912. Point 19 contains the description of two letters sent by Prochaska just before the outbreak of war operations and captured at a post office in Uroševac (Ferizaj). The letters were sent to private addresses. Both letters were forwarded to Prince Alexander. See also docs. 241, 244, 250 (Pašić demanded complete evidence regarding the Prochaska affair). ↩︎
  54. Mirko Gutić (Lt.-Colonel), “Oružani sukobi na srpsko-albanskoj granici u jesen 1913. godine”, Vojnoistorijski glasnik 1 (1985), 242; even the Social Democrats’ newspaper (Radničke novine, of 23 Sept./6 Oct. 1913), highly critical of the government’s Albanian policy, predicted the possible course of events: “This Albanian invasion could cost both sides many and pointless victims […] While they were on the Serbian soil they were plundering, killing and setting on fire. If our troops cross into the Albanian land, they will do the same. Revenge will be horrible.” ↩︎
  55. Gutić, “Oružani sukobi”, 61; “Pokolj u Ljumi,” Radničke novine, 22 Oct./4 Nov. 1913. ↩︎
  56. Gutić, “Oružani sukobi” (based on VA, P 2, box 81, f 12/1, doc. 53/9), 29 Sept. 1913. ↩︎
  57. Ibid. (based on VA, P 2, box 81, f 12/1-2). ↩︎
  58. Ibid. (based on VA, P 2, box 81, f 12/1-4). ↩︎
  59. Ibid. (based on VA, P 2, box 81, f 6/2, doc.28/16). ↩︎
  60. DSPKS, vol. 7/II, doc. 70, pp. 198–201 (most came from the Debar region; some 5,000 in Tirana and some 2,000 in Elbasan); doc. 97, pp. 227–228; doc.131, pp. 260–261; doc. 363, pp. 495-496; doc. 593, pp. 593–594 ↩︎
  61. Alan Kramer, Dynamic of Destruction, Culture and Mass Killing in the First World War (Oxford University Press, 2007) or Jonathan E. Gumz, The Resurrection and Collapse of Empire in Habsburg Serbia, 1914–1918 (Cambridge University Press, 2009); Ferenc Pollman, “Austro-Hungarian Atrocities against Serbians During the WWI”, in Prvi svetski rat i Balkan – 90 godina kasnije/WWI and The Balkans 90 Years Later (Belgrade: Institut za strategijska istraživanja, 2011), 133–142; Dr R. A. Reiss, Rapport sur les atrocités commises par les troupes austro-hongroises pendant la premère invasion de la Serbie présenté au gouvernement Serbe (Paris: B. Grasset, 1919); R. A. Reiss, Comment les Austro-Hongrois ont fait la guerre en Serbie. Observations direct d’un neutre (Paris: A. Colin, 1916); Dr A. Van Tienhoven, Avec les Serbes en Serbie et en Albanie 1914–1916. Journal de guerre d’un chirurgien (Paris: Imprimerie typographique H. Richard, 1918); C. Sturzenegger, Die Wiederauferstehung Serbiens seine gloreichsten und dunkelsten Tage (Bern-Berlin 1920); Henry Barby, La Guerre mondiale. Avec l’Armée serbe (Paris: A. Michel, 1918). ↩︎
  62. Nikola P. Ilić, Oslobodjenje Južne Srbije 1877–1878 (Belgrade: Sloboda, 1977), 152–153; Dr Vladimir Stanojević, Istorija srpskog vojnog saniteta: naše ratno sanitetsko iskustvo (Belgrade: Drzavna stamparija, 1925; 2nd ed., 1992 ), 75; Aleksandar S. Nedok, Balkanski ratovi 1912–Rad srpskog vojnog saniteta (Belgrade: Medija centar Odbrana, 2012), 36, 46. Before the outbreak of the Balkan Wars the Serbian Red Cross was recognized as a important element of society with high international reputation. It was given special recognition by the International Red Cross in Geneva: “…Be as human as Serbia was in 1885…” See Srpski vojni sanitet u
    Balkanskim ratovima
    , eds. Branislav Popović and Veljko Todorović (Belgrade: Medija centar Odbrana, 2012), 230. ↩︎
  63. Stanojević, Istorija srpskog vojnog saniteta, 157–158; Nedok, Balkanski ratovi, 36. ↩︎
  64. Ministarstvo vojno (Sanitetsko odeljenje), Privremeni uput za ratnu sanitetsku službu (Belgrade 1908); CVNDI [Centre for Military-Scientific Documentation and Information, Belgrade], rare doc. no 2022, 34; doc. no. 2022 Belgrade, rare document, no. 2022), 34. The text of the Geneva Convention was included as an appendix. ↩︎
  65. Spomenica sedamdesetpetogodnišnjice Vojne akademije 1850–1925 (Belgrade 1925), 62, 77, 78. ↩︎
  66. “Zarobljenici”, Politika, 23 Oct./5 Nov. 1912; “Novi zarobljenici”, Politika, 24 Oct./6 Nov. 1912; “Dolazak zarobljenika”, Politika, 25 Oct./7 Nov. 1912. ↩︎
  67. “Ranjenici sa Prilepa”, Politika, 3/16 Nov. 1912. It was announced that a train had arrived with 106 wounded Turks out of total of 345 wounded; “Izdržavanje zarobljenika”, Politika, 6/19 November 1912. The article informed about the arrival of another 50 POWs ↩︎
  68. “Premešteni zarobljenici”, Politika, 7/21 Nov. 1912. ↩︎
  69. “Zarobljenici u Nišu”, Politika, 11/24 Nov. 1912. According to Albanian historians from Kosovo, some 650 were sent before 27 October and additional 700 on 30 October 1912 (Isterivanje Albanaca i kolonizacija Kosova II (Priština: Istorijski institut, 1997). ↩︎
  70. Srpske novine no. 1, 1 Jan. 1913. ↩︎
  71. According to The Hague Convention of 1907 (Ch. 2, Art. 12): “Prisoners of war liberated on parole and recaptured bearing arms against the Government to whom they had pledged their honour, forfeit their right to be treated as prisoners of war, and can be brought before the courts.” ↩︎
  72. Ugur Ozcan, “Ottoman prisoners of war and their repatriation challenge in Balkan Wars”, in First Balkan War 1912/1913: The Social and Cultural Meaning, 159–182 (Nis: University of Nis, 2012). ↩︎
  73. “Razmena zarobljenika sutra”, Politika, 1/14 Sept. 1913 ↩︎
  74. The Other Balkan Wars. A 1913 Carnegie Endowment Inquiry, 216 (based on Radničke novine no. 162, 12/25 Aug. 1913). The quoted paragraph gives no indication whatsoever about the motives or context, but the Commission placed full confidence in the alleged witness. The article was based on an anonymous account given in a military hospital. There is no indication where the alleged event took place or which particular unit was involved. ↩︎
  75. Out of 93 reserve hospitals in Serbia, 34 were established in Belgrade alone. Foreign Red Cross missions worked in many of them and even in the permanent Main Military Hospital in Belgrade. See Srpski vojni sanitet u Balkanskim ratovima, 111–113. The Ministry of Education and Religious Affairs closed all schools and the University until October 1913. Female students had the duty to make bandages, sheets, socks, gloves etc. See Srpske novine, 7 Oct. 1912; “Škole – bolnice!”, Politika, 28 Sept./11 Oct. 1912. ↩︎
  76. Stanoje Stanojević, “Bitka na Kumanovu”, Ratnik 2 (1928), 8, 12. ↩︎
  77. Galina Igorevna Sevcova, “Etapna poljska bolnica ‘Grad Moskva’ u Skoplju (Uskub) 8. novembra 1912 – 24. februara 1913“, in Srpski vojni sanitet, 125–130; The Kijevo and Kaufman Red Cross hospitals operated in a large Turkish school (Nedok, Balkanski ratovi, 65). ↩︎
  78. On 6/19 November 1912 the Major and his eight compatriots-medics were granted permission to leave after all patients had been cured (Operations log of the Second Drina Field Hospital). See Nedok, Balkanski ratovi, 98–99; Stanojević, Istorija srpskog vojnog saniteta, 238–239, 248–249 ↩︎
  79. Nedok, Balkanski ratovi, 98 ↩︎
  80. Nedok, Balkanski ratovi, 121–122. ↩︎
  81. Dr Ivan Orežan, Med ranjenimi srbski brati (Ljubljana: Sokolska matica, 1913); Zvonka Zupanič-Slavec and Franc Štolfa, Dr Ivan Orežan, dobrotnik Medicinske fakultete in slovenskega naroda (Ljubljana: Medicinska fakulteta, 1998); C. Sturzenegger, Serbisches Rotes Kreuz und internationale Liebestaetigkeit waehrend der Balkankriege 1912/1913 (Zurich: Orell Fuessli, 1914), 1–128; Tangeberg, ”Semi-barbarians”, 55–72. ↩︎

Bibliography

Map of our blog posts. Go forth and discover something close to you!

Scroll to Top